Hands down my favorite liquid eyeliner. It is very black and extremely waterproof! It is hard for me to find an eyeliner that doesn't smudge or fade away. This eyeliner will look exactly the same as when first applied to the end of a long day. The only two downsides to this product is that it is impossible to fix a mistake without makeup remover because it drys down extremely fast. And if it gets in my eyelashes, it will make them clumpy looking so I need to comb them out as soon as I finish my liner. Negatives aside, this is a great product. I only wish they would come out with more colors again.